NCAA
NCAA

Is Arch Manning a true Heisman Trohpy candidate? The hype raises questions after evaluation for the 2025 season

And people could second guess themselves

Arch Manning scrambles past a Florida defensive back during a game.
Arch Manning scrambles past a Florida defensive back during a game.LAPRESSE

As Arch Manning enters his third collegiate season at Texas, the hype surrounding him has reached an all-time high. The 21-year-old quarterback is widely considered a Heisman Trophy favorite, with the Longhorns ranked among the country's top teams in early polling. His name is already being floated atop 2026 NFL Draft boards, despite limited playing time as a starter. While many analysts are praising his potential, others question whether Manning's fame is driving the hype more than his on-field résumé.

Fox Sports analyst Joel Klatt is among Manning's most vocal ers, recently declaring him the second-best quarterback in college football during an appearance on The Herd. Klatt cited Manning's ability to threaten defenses with his arm strength, accuracy, and intelligence, comparing him to former Clemson star Trevor Lawrence.

Cam Ward wows Titans coaches with fastest release and sharp es at training camp

Host Colin Cowherd embraced Klatt's assessment, but not everyone is convinced. Manning spent most of last season backing up Quinn Ewers, who played through a torn oblique injury, leaving some to wonder why head coach Steve Sarkisian didn't turn to Manning earlier if he was truly ready.

Steelers Discuss Trade for Jonnu Smith with Dolphins

So, then, what will happen?

The debate over Manning's legitimacy as an elite prospect has sparked heated discussions. While his talent is evident, skeptics argue that his last name has amplified his reputation beyond what he has proven on the field. Former Georgia quarterback Aaron Murray has voiced concerns about Manning's rapid rise, questioning why Texas didn't hand him the reins last season when Ewers struggled. Others wonder how Manning will handle the transition to the SEC, where defenses are known to be tougher and more physical.

Still, Manning's ers believe his breakout moment is coming. NFL Draft analysts have praised his mechanics, footwork, and ability to lead an offense, with many projecting him as a future first-round pick. Texas' national title hopes also play into the excitement, as Manning is expected to play a key role in the Longhorns' championship aspirations. His skill set, combined with the team's talent, could put him in the Heisman conversation well into the season.

The campaign will be a defining moment for Manning as he works to silence critics and prove he can live up to his growing expectations. If he delivers on the field and guides Texas to the College Football Playoff, his status as an elite quarterback will be cemented. However, if he struggles or fails to separate himself from other top ers, the conversation surrounding his hype will only intensify.

As the college football season nears, all eyes will be on Manning and the Longhorns. Whether he rises to the occasion or faces increased scrutiny, his journey promises to be one of the most compelling storylines in the sport.

NCAAIs Arch Manning ready for the starting job at Texas? The real test will take place later in the season and then people will now the truth
NCAAArch Manning called overrated as Heisman favorite and NIL top star faces critics by SEC historic leader
NCAABrowns could target Arch Manning in 2026 after predicted 0-5 collapse