As the Cleveland Browns approach the 2025 NFL season, their quarterback situation is notably complex due to Deshaun Watson's season-long absence with a torn Achilles. With that in mind, Shedeur Sanders, Joe Flacco, Dillon Gabriel, and Kenny Pickett are all competing for the QB1 role - so we asked AI (ChatGPT) for its predictions on the quarterback battle in Cleveland.
With uncertainty looming over the Browns' quarterback room, fans and analysts are speculating how the depth chart will shake out come Week 1. Between seasoned veterans and promising rookies, the competition is wide open and each candidate brings a unique set of skills and questions. So, what's the most likely outcome?
Browns QB1 in Week 1
QB1 AI prediction: Joe Flacco
AI analysis: The Browns are in win-now mode despite Watson's injury. Flacco is the only proven veteran on the roster and already has chemistry with Stefanski's offense. He starts Week 1 unless something drastic happens in training camp.
QB2 AI prediction: Dillon Gabriel
AI analysis: The Browns used a 3rd-round pick on Gabriel. That investment matters. He's accurate, smart, and viewed as more "NFL-ready" out of the gate than Shedeur. He'll be first in if Flacco goes down.
QB3 AI prediction: Shedeur Sanders
AI analysis: Shedeur is loaded with potential and already flashing it. But as a 5th-round pick, he's still viewed as a developmental QB. Expect him to sit, learn, and build chemistry with the second team - but if Flacco struggles and Gabriel plateaus, Shedeur could leapfrog into action midseason.
QB4 AI prediction: Kenny Pickett
AI analysis: There's no clear long-term investment in Pickett. He's trade bait or could even be cut if he doesn't outperform either rookie in camp. If he sticks, he's emergency depth at best.
QB1 end of 2025 Season Predictions
QB1 AI prediction: Shedeur Sanders
AI analysis: Emerging as the clear starter after proving his talent and poise throughout the season. He'll bring youthful energy and potential to lead the Browns moving forward.
QB2 AI prediction: Dillon Gabriel
AI analysis: Gets meaningful playing time due to rotation or injury but ultimately doesn't supplant Shedeur as the starter. Remains a solid backup with upside.
QB3 AI prediction: Joe Flacco
AI analysis: Veteran presence who likely starts early but moves to a backup role as the team transitions to younger quarterbacks.
QB4 AI prediction: Kenny Pickett
AI analysis: Either moved on or retained as emergency depth with limited or no game action.